Follow Us:
A rundown of various iPhone 4S reviews
The iPhone 4S is officially launching on Friday and the early reviews of the upgraded device are in. While the device is physically the same, several publications in the United States have posted their thoughts on Siri, the new A5 processor and the camera. Here’s a good breakdown from each.
Various opening lines:
Wired:
“Apple never specified what the “S” stands for in iPhone 4S, and it may as well stand for Siri.”
The Verge:
“Reviewing the iPhone 4S is in many ways a lot like reviewing the original iPhone 4, except that it’s not. The device, which was just announced at a special event on Apple’s campus, is very much the same phone the company released in June of 2010 — but it’s also something completely new.”
New York Times:
“A lot, apparently. Apple’s new iPhone is called the iPhone 4S. But what people really wanted was the iPhone 5.”
USA Today:
“As the iconic smartphone for these times, any new iPhone would make a huge splash.”
Daring Fireball:
“This is the easiest product review I’ve ever written. The iPhone 4S is exactly what Apple says it is: just like the iPhone 4, but noticeably faster, with a significantly improved camera, and an impressive new voice-driven feature called Siri.”
The new A5 Dual-core processor:
Tech Crunch:
“First of all, the iPhone 4S blows away the iPhone 4 when it comes to speed. For the past week, I’ve been testing all of my most-used apps and the differences range from solid to awesome. At first glance, the speed difference may seem subtle. But over time, it adds up and becomes apparent. I would switch back to my iPhone 4 and get frustrated by the lag”.
The Verge:
“apps seemed to open a little bit faster, and the camera response time is noticeably improved. The 4S is definitely a snappy device, but if you’re going from the last version to this, it feels like a tweak, not an overhaul. It’s possible that newer software (Infinity Blade 2, for instance) will take better advantage of the A5′s capabilities, but that remains to be seen.”
New York Times:
“There’s a faster chip, the same one that’s in the iPad 2. More speed is always better, of course. But it’s not like people were complaining about the previous iPhone’s speed.”
The 8-megapixel Camera:
Daring Fireball:
“The most profound difference between the 4S and 4 cameras has nothing to do with image quality. It’s that you don’t have to wait nearly as long. That closed iris comes up for a moment and then it’s gone, and you’re ready to shoot. And after you shoot, the camera is ready to snap additional photos almost instantly. The difference is huge, and it’s especially nice in conjunction with iOS 5’s new lock screen shortcut to jump right into the Camera app.”
New York Times:
“A much better, faster camera — among the best on a phone. It has a resolution of eight megapixels, which doesn’t matter much, and a new, more light-sensitive sensor, which does. Its photos are crisp and clear, with beautiful color. The low-light photos and 1080p high-definition video are especially impressive for a phone. There’s still no zoom and only a tiny LED flash — but otherwise, this phone comes dangerously close to displacing a $200 point-and-shoot digital camera.”
Tech Crunch:
“Also great is that the iPhone 4S camera can shoot 1080p video for the first time. The iPhone 4 is limited to 720p. The 4S also features video stabilization, to ensure your home videos won’t make viewers want to vomit. Testing this out, it seems to work pretty well.”
USA Today:
“The camera has 8 megapixels (up from 5 megapixels in the iPhone 4), but the megapixel count doesn’t nearly tell the whole story. Among other things, Apple engineered the sensor so it will let in a lot more light. It added face detection, too, for detecting whether you’re capturing a portrait or group shot. And the camera fires up and lets you shoot the next picture in a snap.”
The Verge:
“Apple has introduced a number of improvements on the video side, including image stabilization, and it shows when you’re shooting even relatively fast action. There’s not much to say except that Apple has improved on what was already a capable video solution, making it a full-fledged competitor for bulkier point-and-shoots or dedicated camcorders.”
Slash Gear:
“Does it all work? You bet it does. There are two noticeable improvements – quality and speed – and the best thing is that they’re clearly evident from the start. Sharpness and detail are significantly boosted in the iPhone 4S when compared to what the iPhone 4 can achieve; there’s less noise and less color bleed evident. Aberrations such as fringing around the edges of the frame are cut right back, a benefit of that five-lens array.”
Siri – The “Intelligent Assistant:
All Things D:
“The standout feature, not available in other iPhones, or in any other phone I’ve seen, is Siri. It answers questions and provides information using natural language and an intelligent understanding, not just of words, but of context and colloquial phrasing. It isn’t perfect, and is labeled a beta, but it has great potential and worked pretty well for me, despite some glitches.”
Daring Fireball:
“In a sense, Siri is like a second interface to iOS. The first interface is the app interface. Launch, tap, drag, slide. The Siri interface is a different world. As stated above, this new interface is in many ways the opposite of the regular one — open-ended and implicit instead of narrowly defined and explicit. I don’t mean to imply that Siri doesn’t fit in or feel right at home — it does. But Siri is indicative of an AI-focused ambition that Apple hasn’t shown since before Steve Jobs returned to the company. Prior to Siri, iOS struck me being designed to make it easy for us to do things. Siri is designed to do things for us.”
New York Times:
“In each case, Siri thinks for a few seconds, displays a beautifully formatted response and speaks in a calm female voice. It’s mind-blowing how inexact your utterances can be… It’s even more amazing how Siri’s responses can actually form a conversation. Once, I tried saying, “Make an appointment with Patrick for Thursday at 3.” Siri responded, “Note that you already have an all-day appointment about ‘Boston Trip’ for this Thursday. Shall I schedule this anyway?” Unbelievable. ”
Wired:
“It’s kind of like having the unpaid intern of my dreams at my beck and call, organizing my life for me. I think Siri on the iPhone is a life changer, and this is only the beginning.”
The Verge:
“Siri can be helpful, but was also frustrating at times. Seeing the software mangle a request or fail to understand what action you want it to take can be maddening, but I think that frustration actually speaks to how advanced the software is. Siri is capable of doing so much that is complex that I started giving it more credit than was probably due. I expected Siri to be smarter than it is right now, because… well, it’s already pretty damn smart.”
iOS 5:
Tech Crunch:
“The best addition to iOS 5 is the revamped Notifications system. Yes, it’s a bit like the system that Android and webOS have had for a while, but once again, Apple took their time to make sure they did this right. Gone are the annoying blue pop-ups that would get lost when another notification came in. Now you have a full-on notification center to keep track of everything you miss when you’re away from your phone or simply not in the mood to check it.”
USA Today:
“The new software is the iOS 5 mobile operating system, which introduces more than 200 features, including a handy and unobtrusive way of delivering notifications of texts, e-mails, missed calls, stock prices, appointments and more. All you need do is swipe down from the top of the device, not unlike on Android phones. And you’ll see notifications on the iPhone lock screen. Twitter integration also arrives with iOS 5, as does the iMessage service that lets you send texts, photos, videos and locations to friends or contacts who also have iOS 5 devices.”
Daring Fireball:
“The iOS interface is fundamentally only two levels deep: the first level is the home screen, listing all available apps. The second level is when you tap an app to use it. Hit the home button to go back to the home screen. That’s it.”
The Verge:
“iOS 5 is a huge update — maybe Apple’s biggest ever — and there’s lots to unpack… For starters, don’t expect a completely new look and feel to the operating system. iOS 5 is nearly identical to the last version of the OS, save for some pretty notable improvements in functionality. The biggest and probably most desired (at least by more tech-savvy users) is improved notifications.”
Conclusions:
All Things D:
“The iPhone 4S is one of Apple’s less dramatic updates, but, when combined with the Siri, iOS 5 and iCloud features, it presents an attractive new offering to smartphone users. Some may be content to skip the new hardware and just enjoy the software and cloud features with older models. But those buying the phone will likely be happy with it.”
The Verge:
“Is this the best phone ever made? That’s debatable. But I can tell you this: the iPhone 4S is pretty damn cool.”
New York Times:
“Android phones seem to come out every Tuesday at 3:45 p.m. Apple updates iOS and the iPhone only once a year. So Apple had a lot of catching up to do, even some leapfrogging. There are some rough spots here and there; for example, every now and then the 4S’s camera app gets stuck on its startup screen. And while the battery still gets you through one full day, standby time is shorter than before (200 hours versus 300). But over all, Apple has done an excellent job.”
Daring Fireball:
“The iPhone 4 was my favorite product that Apple has ever made. The iPhone 4S has all the best features of the iPhone 4 — same look, same feel, same Retina Display — and adds several significant improvements. The one and only disappointment I have with the iPhone 4S is that the shutdown spinner animation is still low-res. That’s pretty low on the list of nits to pick.”
Read all the full review of the iPhone 4S here: The Verge; New York Times; USA Today; Wired; Tech Crunch; Daring Fireball; Slash Gear and All Things D
Discussion
31 comments for “A rundown of various iPhone 4S reviews”
Post a comment
- CES 2012
- Mobile News
- Airtel Wireless
- Bell Mobility News
- Chatr
- Clearnet
- Eastlink
- Fido News
- Globalive News
- Koodo Mobile News
- Mobilicity
- MTS
- NorthernTel
- PC Mobile News
- Petro-Canada Mobility
- Primus Wireless News
- Public Mobile
- Rogers Wireless News
- SaskTel News
- Shaw
- Solo Mobile News
- Speak Out Wireless News
- tbaytel
- Telus Mobility News
- Vidéotron News
- Virgin Mobile News
- WIND Mobile
- Reviews – Carrier
- Reviews – Manufacturer
- Various News
Canada’s Sync/Sympatico: http://www.sync-blog.com/sync/2011/10/iphone-4s-review-dont-knock-it-til-you-try-it.html
Like or Dislike:
3 
0
omg let the steve jobs necro 8======D riding begin!!! u guys are pathetic u will take anything apple releases and think its the greatest thing since sliced bread. get off apples 8====D already and get a better phone ie. android htc sensation and the SG2 destroys this phone and the next androids that come will destroy all and apple will die along with jobs!!!! thats why 70% of ppl say there next phone will be an android!!! HAHA
Like or Dislike:
11 
15
Tech Crunch:
“First of all, the iPhone 4S blows away the iPhone 4 when it comes to speed. (…) At first glance, the speed difference may seem subtle.”
So, the speed difference is difficult to notice but he first stated that it “blows away” the iphone 4. And down the drain goes the credibility of his review.
Like or Dislike:
32 
12
I think it’s a fair comment by Tech Crunch. The previous iPhones were already more efficient than their on paper specs would lead you to believe. Other phones with better specs don’t actually run their OS or apps nearly as fast. So what I take Tech Crunch’s analysis to mean is; while the 4s [b]hardware[/b] is a significant upgrade over the 4, the [b]software[/b] already runs so fast that you might not see the difference (at least until new apps are written to take advantage of the available power).
Like or Dislike:
12 
3
So pumped for this phone, sure it looks the same, but why fix what aint broken? The shell for the iPhone 4 is a solid make, sleek, sexy and functional. But don’t kid yourself, this IS a new phone underneath. I am very excited to see Siri work first hand, and the addition of the A5 dual core can only speed things up. The camera, so far, looks amazing, and it may finally be time to see great looking pics uploaded from my phone. The reviews don’t lie, yes, it was disappointing that the phone looks identical to its predecessor, but all the new additions make this a NEW phone. Very excited to see it roll out Friday.
Like or Dislike:
21 
19
initially i thought this wasn’t the best phone but now that i think about it, i think this was a good move on apple’s part. This still offers iphone 4 users an incentive to keep their phone and only missing out on maybe 1-2 features. Sure it looks the same but the insides are entirely new which will make a difference, lets hope the antenna problem is fully solved!
I still don’t get why Siri is not on the iphone 4, i am sure it can handle it no?
Like or Dislike:
10 
1
“The device, which was just announced at a special event on Apple’s campus, is very much the same phone the company released in June of 2010 — but it’s also something completely new.”
This is the kind of thing that rubs non-Apple people the wrong way – buying into and reinforcing the hype created by what is, despite what people like to think, a large and greedy corporation.
The Nexus S, which had a curved screen and NFC, was not something completely new. The Nexus Prime, with a 720p screen, and no buttons, isn’t something completely new. The iPhone 4S, which is literally just an iPhone 4 with a better processor/camera and voice controls, is not something completely new either. It’s a spec bump from a previous model that’s aesthetically indistinguishable from its predecessor. I’m not suggesting it’s a bad phone – the iPhone 4 is a great phone and I have don’t doubt this will be marginally better. But that’s the whole point… marginally.
Like or Dislike:
32 
5
Good news. As I always said iOS is one of the smoothest and doesn’t need quadcore to make it work flawlessly.
Like or Dislike:
14 
15
So there is no bad review, no reviews saying that the phone is no big deal only review saying that the phone is awesome?
Like or Dislike:
14 
2
The iPhone 4S is a great phone, one of the bests, not THE best.
It’s not revolutionary anymore. It’s just the new iPhone for 2011. Next year iPhone we’ll be better/faster…
Not sure it worth 649$+tx (the price you pay for it anyway, with-or-without contract)
And don’t tell me Apple kept the same design only because it’s a great design (even if it’s a great one), they kept it because it’s cost-effective too.
Like or Dislike:
11 
1
Not revolutionary ?
I think siri is a big step in the right direction and should deff be considered revolutionary.
I will bet ya now that other companies will be following suite with upgrading their voice to text programs. In this day and age it is not hardware that is gonna bring people to a phone but more software
Like or Dislike:
9 
12
@ Rio
Siri is NOT revolutionary. Vlingo has been out for awhile. The Galaxy S II (out for months already) has it built in. All I have to do is double tap the home button, and the phone asks me what I want to do (Or I can say “Hi Galaxy” and it will then ask me).
I can do the usual dial by name or number, but I can also get directions (Navigation), text message, email, check the weather, Facebook, Tweet, play music, etc. In “car mode” it will read emails and texts to me, and allow me to dictate the replies.
Siri may do it better (not sure though, from the reviews I’ve read), but it is obviously not “revolutionary”.
Like or Dislike:
14 
3
So… How about an iphone without a screen that breaks easily?
Like or Dislike:
14 
5
Apple steals android tech with notification change.. Pretty revolutionary tho…
Like or Dislike:
13 
7
Hidden due to low comment rating. Click here to see.
Like or Dislike:
5 
25
What do you mean there’s a difference? Regardless, copying is still copying
It’s like cheating on a test. No matter how elegant you did it, it’s still cheating.
Like or Dislike:
11 
1
Am I the only one that think that Siri (or any voice control) is completely useless? And why is it 4S only and not for the iphone 4/3gs? That’s marketing bullsh*t!!!
NYT made an interesting remark too, standby time is now “up to 200 hours” down from 300 hours. Also, wifi browsing is down to 9 hours (from 10 hours) but 3g talk time is up to 8 hours (from 7). 33% decrease in standby time? That sucks big time!
Like or Dislike:
9 
5
Hidden due to low comment rating. Click here to see.
Like or Dislike:
4 
20
I’M SO GETTING ONE! NEW IPHONE!??
And selling it for Galaxy Nexus
Like or Dislike:
14 
6
“The iPhone 4S is a great phone, one of the bests, not THE best.”
A friend of mine says he owns THE best car. It’s been sitting in his driveway for weeks waiting for parts. I’ve been through several generations of smartphones and spent countless hours trying to make them work they way they were supposed to. But life is short. I want them working smoothly out of the box without having to worry about crapware, malware, viruses, etc., and being at the mercy of Google AND the harware manufacturer AND my provider when it comes to OS upgrades. I also like the huge choice of quality software and accessories. Nothing touches the iPhone ecosystem at this time.
Like or Dislike:
3 
5
@Rio, uh that’s exactly what Samsung did (to an extent) with their phone software ui design; took a concept and improved it 10-folds. However, it’s only called infringement when anyone besides Apple does it.
Like or Dislike:
11 
1
Ey Rio before getting all religious on Siri, remember its not even something they developed…just something they bought and added on…
Like or Dislike:
6 
0
And a good article to read is Stephen Fry’s review for Guardian, quite well written as is everything he does.
Nothings going to pry my Samsung Galaxy SII from my hands though.
Like or Dislike:
1 
0
My comments?
Its a great phone, but thats it. Previous Apple outings have released something that other companies needed to strive for, they were amazing, this is simply as good.
Yes it has some features like Siri which will and already are being done, maybe not trying to give the impression that it is artificial intelligence like Siri does, but its out there. Lets not forget that Siri was around and working on this before Apple bought them.
Like or Dislike:
3 
0
“Apple steals android tech with notification change.. Pretty revolutionary tho…
”
And with ICS Android will merge the tablet and phone experience into one,now who did that first? Pretty revolutionary right?
Like or Dislike:
3 
8
Is anybody already trying to pretend it’s gonna be revolutionnary? I don’t think so. It’s not the way Google act.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
I’m confused by this review. It does not state whether it’s a floater or a sinker. Hard or loose?
Like or Dislike:
2 
0
My review:
-still slower than the dual core android devices that have now been out for 6 months plus
-camera is good, has now caught up to the latest devices
-siri is cool, android already has some of this and has for sometime, but apple has taken it further and made it better
-needs a new screen, way behind devices that have been out for awhile
Like or Dislike:
2 
0
Slower David? really, then why did it benchmark FASTER then the SGS2? Actually its TWICE as fast, its even FASTER then the Galaxy Tab!
http://www.techspot.com/news/45814-apple-iphone-4s-benchmark-results-leaked.html
Now go ahead with the next excuse…
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
I see the battery is almost dead… SHOCKER!!!
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Apple is brilliant. Not only do they take whatever they want and call it their own, they convince/buy reviewers to give their truly biased opinion. If Samsung put out the exact same phone with slightly improved specs it would have been declared that Samsung has lost its touch. But all that doesn’t matter as Apple controls their customers as long as they don’t think for themselves. Well done Apple.
Like or Dislike:
2 
0