Lobbyists and executives from Meta, Apple, and Google’s parent company, Alphabet, are mounting a final effort to rewrite Bill C-22 before it officially passes.
The bill, known as the “lawful access” bill, is designed to allow Canada’s investigative agencies and police services to compel tech companies to retain and turn over some previously encrypted data. Although controversial, the Canadian government insists the measures align the country with its Five Eyes and Group of Seven allies.
However, tech companies have pushed back on the lawful access bill for months, arguing that the bill as written would still allow the government to issue secret orders that weaken encryption.
On Monday, leaders from Meta, Signal, and Tailscale argued against the bill at a Senate committee hearing designed to shape its final form. This committee is the bill’s last hurdle before it could potentially pass into law, and it rarely rejects bills—but it often secures amendments.
Now, tech companies argue that the bill goes far beyond what other countries have adopted, and warn that having a backdoor into previously encrypted data could compromise Canadians’ privacy. Yahoo Finance (Bloomberg) added that Meta has argued the law would effectively make its platforms “an arm of the government’s surveillance apparatus.”
Meta even threatened to pull services like WhatsApp from Canada if Bill C-22 passes, according to a CBC News report. Now, Meta is not the only company that is threatening this. Signal stated back in May that if it is asked to comply with Bill C-22, it could pull its services from Canada.
Apple hasn’t gone that far yet, but it previously said it “will never” add a backdoor to its products. Apple also provided the following statement to MobileSyrup:
“At Apple, we believe privacy is a fundamental human right. It’s one of our core values, which is why we minimize the data we collect and design our products from the ground up to protect users’ most sensitive data. While we appreciate attempts to improve C-22, the bill could still undermine Apple’s ability to offer the powerful privacy and security features our users expect from us, including encryption, even as AI and other evolving technologies provide hackers with new tools to exploit cybersecurity weaknesses. You can’t build a backdoor just for the good guys, yet C-22 could force companies to build backdoors into products — something Apple will never do. We are proud of our longstanding cooperation with Canadian law enforcement to protect public safety. Unfortunately, C-22, as drafted, puts the privacy and security of Canadian users at risk.”
The government has been trying to get this bill into law as quickly as possible, with Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree telling the National Post that “my expectation is to get it done before we rise. I want this as law before we rise.”
The federal government has been rushing this bill, including pushing it through the House of Commons right before it rose for summer break in June.
Source: Yahoo Finance (Bloomberg)
Image Credit: Shutterstock
Business
News
Business
News